I attended a middle school Remembrance Day ceremony today. It didn't leave me feeling reflective, pensive or proud, rather, it left filled with anger at the sham that was performed for the indoctrination of young minds.
From the sappy song about how music can change the world, to the sombre speech talking about how our ancestors fought and died for inclusion and progress, to how the duty and sacrifice of so many should remind us of the importance of freedom.
We constantly talk about the notion that we should never forget the sacrifice of those who have served, of those who gave their lives to defend our country and ensure our freedom, but we never take a moment to reflect on the ever growing disparity between the world our ancestors fought and died to defend and the world that we have built upon that sacrifice. That is where my anger is rooted, in that ever growing divide and in the way that we use their sacrifice to somehow sanitize our betrayal of that very same sacrifice.
Today we were told that the exmple of our their sacrifice and duty was for freedom. It is not meant to invoke in us a sense of sacrifice and duty ourselves, but rather we are to herald our "freedom" as the ultiimate end, even though we do not live in a free country. Are we more free than in other countries? To be sure, but that does not mean that we are actually free.
Canada was birthed in the rejection of freedom, in our continued subjugation to a monarch and foreign government (notice how we sang God Save the King at the end). Our "sovereign" government was developed over many years of ensuring that power stayed as far from the hands of the people as possible. Today we herald our "freedom" and provide as evidence that we live in a democracy, yet "the word comes from the ancient Greek words dēmos (meaning "people" or "the masses") and kratos (meaning "strength," "power," or "rule"), literally translating to "rule by the people"" Do we as people rule ourselves? No. That power is denied us through the notion of "representation". Democracy now means choosing a person who was rejected by the majority of people to govern us without accountability or responsibility. I personally describe our form of government as a pseudo-democratically elected representative oligarchy, where the few rule over the many.
Our leaders stand before us and give speeches about how our ancestors sacrificed for "our way of life" but if we are honest with ourselves, the world that we have created would horrify our ancestors. We openly denegrate the memory of their world and destroy the monuments erected to commemorate the world that they sought to defend, and call it progress. I call it spitting on their graves and memories.
We've built a world that argues and fights for the murder of unborn children, that celebrates a mother who openly confessed to murdering her children, that calls for and celebrates political assassination, that gives standing ovations to literal nazis in the houses of parliament, that defends a woman who seeks to destroy the lives of men who participated with her in a drunken drug-fueled g**gb**g, not becuase she thinks what they did was wrong, but rather to avoid public shame over her participation. Do we honestly think that the world that we have created on their sacrifice honours their memory? That the world they sought to defend still exists?
Canadians fought and died to defeat nazism and communism, yet we support and celebrate nazis and have become communist ourselves, then have the temerity to stand up once a year and call on the memory of our ancestor's sacrifice as though in invoking their memory we somehow sanitize the ways that we have betrayed their memory and their sacrifice.
Year after year we invoke the poem In Flanders Fields, and betray its call to duty and sacrifice, the very virtues that these men demonstrated with their very lives.
In Flanders fields the poppies blow
Between the crosses, row on row,
That mark our place; and in the sky
The larks, still bravely singing, fly
Scarce heard amid the guns below.
We are the Dead. Short days ago
We lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow,
Loved and were loved, and now we lie,
In Flanders fields.
Take up our quarrel with the foe:
To you from failing hands we throw
The torch; be yours to hold it high.
If ye break faith with us who die
We shall not sleep, though poppies grow
In Flanders fields.
We have broken faith with the dead, we have betrayed their memory, and so they "shall not sleep" because we, rather than taking "up our quarrel with the foe," chose instead to become the foe and to call on the shades of their memory as ceremonial insult to their sacrifice.
Then we stand there, with heads bowed, singing our national anthem (which is a lie), staying silent for a bit and giving melodramatic speeches all meant to infuse in the minds of children that the world they inhabit somehow honours the memory of these fallen soldiers, to indoctrinate them into a hedonistic solipsistic culture that recoils from the very virtues that made it possible; duty, sacrifice, honour, faith.
To those of us who remember, who truly remember, Remembrance Day is not a solemn day for remembring and then ignoring the sacrifice that came before us, it is the reopening of a wound, a reminder that there is a battle to be fought, the struggle continues, that we are to catch the torch thrown by failing hands, so that the light can ever shine in the darkness.
Deus Vult